My Life! Teaching in a Korean University

  • ESL Korea
  • Teaching English
  • ESL Activities
  • Learning English

in Life in the Classroom

Teaching Writing Strategies: Fostering Student Autonomy

Student Autonomy with Self-Editing

Fostering Student Autonomy in Writing Classes

Autonomy, with regards to teaching is when students take charge of their own learning–when they are responsible for it and the teacher is more of a guide than the all-knowing one who imparts wisdom and knowledge.

Teacher as Editor Model: Bad News!

I believe that the current model of teaching writing in most universities in Korea (and perhaps around the world where English is taught as a second or foreign language) does nothing to foster student autonomy. When I attend conferences, I hear people giving presentations about teaching writing without even a mention of self-editing, instead focusing on teacher, or peer-editing exclusively, which I find quite bizarre.

This model of teacher-editing is basically where the student writes something and gives it to the teacher, probably with very little in the way of self-editing, if any at all.

In fact, it’s not so uncommon that the student, especially at lower-levels will give something to the teacher that came straight from Google Translate. Then the teacher spends ridiculous amounts of time editing something that in some cases is barely understandable and gives it back to the student. They make the changes, often mindlessly and don’t really look at the mistakes in detail.

Repeat this cycle endlessly.

40+ ESL activities, delivered straight to your inbox:

* indicates required


Peer as Editor: Bad New Also!

This cycle can also be done with peer-editing, of which I am not a big fan of either. In both of these models, the learner essentially takes very little responsibility for turning out a quality product on their own because they know that the teacher or friend will just make the changes they need.

However, peer or teacher-editing is 100% unlike real-life. When students are taking an English proficiency test that involves writing, there is no teacher or friend sitting next to them, helping them along. Nor would they have this at any job. They would just be expected to turn out a decent email or essay or whatever else they would need to write. No hand-holding to fall back on!

How about Teaching Self-Editing?

In an attempt to foster student autonomy by teaching writing strategies, I’m teaching students to self-edit by giving them check-lists with things like:

Check all the verbs: correct tense?

What is your thesis statement? Is it stated or implied?

Does each sentence have a capital letter and period/question mark/exclamation point.

Jackie: You’re So Mean!

However, I’m not totally unkind. If a student comes to my office during office hours, I’ll read essays and give general feedback like, “Your hook is quite weak…what about changing it to something like…”

Yes, it’s challenging for the students. No, I’m not just lazy. 

But, isn’t this what student-centred teaching is all about?

ESL Writing Activities, Games & Teaching Tips: Practical Ideas for the Classroom (ESL Activities for...
11 Reviews
ESL Writing Activities, Games & Teaching Tips: Practical Ideas for the Classroom (ESL Activities for...
  • Bolen, Jackie (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 72 Pages - 12/09/2019 (Publication Date) - Independently published (Publisher)
Check Price on Amazon

Self-Editing = a skill for life. Teacher-editing = not so much

I truly think that teaching self-editing will be better for the students in the end, even if they are not so happy about it in the meantime. I hope to give them skills they can take beyond my class to the real world and self-editing is definitely one of those things. Students generally hate what is not easy for them, but spoon-feeding has really never been my style. Sorry, my lazy students. I’m not the teacher for you!

Want to get a university job in South Korea?
How to Get a University Job in South Korea: The English Teaching Job of Your Dreams

What Do You Think about Teaching Writing Strategies?

What do you do in your own writing classes? Leave a comment below and let us know your thoughts. We’d love to hear from you.

Also be sure to give this article a share on Facebook, Pinterest, or Twitter. It’ll help other busy English teachers, like yourself find this useful resource.

Last update on 2022-06-17 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

About Jackie

Jackie Bolen has been teaching English for more than 15 years to students in South Korea and Canada. She's taught all ages, levels and kinds of TEFL classes. She holds an MA degree, along with the Celta and Delta English teaching certifications.

Jackie is the author of more than 30 books for English teachers and English learners, including Advanced English Conversation Dialogues and 39 No-Prep/Low-Prep ESL Speaking Activities for Teenagers and Adults. She loves to share her ESL games, activities, teaching tips, and more with other teachers throughout the world.

You can find her on social media at:
Facebook
Pinterest

« Great Writing 4 by Keith Folse Review | Teaching ESL Writing
The Korean ESL Industry is Not What it Once Was: Learn More Here »
Great Debates for ESL/EFL: 39 Important Debating Topics for English Learners
Great Debates for ESL/EFL: 39 Important Debating Topics for English Learners
Check Price on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. What does this mean? I recommend products (only ones that I like) and if you purchase a product through that link, I earn some money.

103 Fun ESL Games & Activities for the Classroom : Interactive, Minimal Prep TEFL Ideas for All Ages
103 Fun ESL Games & Activities for the Classroom : Interactive, Minimal Prep TEFL Ideas for All Ages
Check Price on Amazon
67 ESL Conversation Topics with Questions, Vocabulary, Writing Prompts & More: For English Teachers...
67 ESL Conversation Topics with Questions, Vocabulary, Writing Prompts & More: For English Teachers...
Check Price on Amazon
39 ESL Warm-Ups: For Teachers of Teenagers and Adults who Want to Start Their English Classes Off...
39 ESL Warm-Ups: For Teachers of Teenagers and Adults who Want to Start Their English Classes Off...
Check Price on Amazon
39 No-Prep/Low-Prep ESL Speaking Activities: For English Teachers of Teenagers and Adults Who Want...
39 No-Prep/Low-Prep ESL Speaking Activities: For English Teachers of Teenagers and Adults Who Want...
Check Price on Amazon

More ESL Activities & Games

39 Task-Based Language Teaching and Learning Activities: A Very Practical Guide to Using TBL in the...
39 Task-Based Language Teaching and Learning Activities: A Very Practical Guide to Using TBL in the...
Check Price on Amazon

Recent Posts

  • Fun Would You Rather Questions for Adults | ESL Conversation
  • Christmas ESL Activities, Games, Lesson Plans, Worksheets & More
  • Spelling Games for the Classroom: Fun ESL Spelling Activities
  • The Best Tips for Giving Instructions to ESL Students
101 Activities and Resources for Teaching English Online: Practical Ideas, Games, Activities & Tips...
101 Activities and Resources for Teaching English Online: Practical Ideas, Games, Activities & Tips...
Check Price on Amazon
Sale 101 ESL Activities: For Teenagers and Adults
101 ESL Activities: For Teenagers and Adults
Check Price on Amazon

About and Contact

Jackie Bolen has been talking ESL South Korea since 2014. The goal is to bring you the best tips, ideas, and news for everything teaching English in Korea, including university jobs.

Contact Jackie Bolen and My Life! Teaching in a Korean University here.

Email: [email protected]

Address: 2436 Kelly Ave, Port Coquitlam, Canada

Find the Privacy Policy here.

Facebook

Pinterest

TikTok

YouTube

LinkedIn

Best Seller

101 ESL Activities: Games, Activities, Practical ideas, & Teaching Tips For English Teachers of...
101 ESL Activities: Games, Activities, Practical ideas, & Teaching Tips For English Teachers of...
Check Price on Amazon

Search

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Advertise on My Life! Teaching in Korean University

Recent Articles

student-name-tags

Name Tags for Students in the Classroom | Making Nametags

teaching-esl-online

Activities and Resources to Teach ESL Online

website resources for esl teachers

The 10 Best Websites for ESL Teachers

easter-esl-activities-games

ESL Easter Activities, Classroom Games, Lesson Plans & Resources

Copyright © 2023 Jackie Bolen + My Life! Teaching in a Korean University. All Rights Reserved.