A Review of Touchstone 4-Skills ESL Textbook
Touchstone is a 4-skills (reading, writing, listening, speaking) ESL textbook for adults published by Cambridge. There are 4 levels, ranging from 1-4. Touchstone 1 is reasonably easy and would generally be suitable for an average freshman English class in Korea. Touchstone 4 is much harder and even third or fourth year English majors in Korea would probably struggle with it. It’s better for Europeans, or other students who have higher levels of English ability than students in Korea.
Old Touchstone: Hated It!
I used the old edition years ago and distinctly remember loathing it. It had all these ridiculous speak like a “native speaker” sections, which I fundamentally disagree with. If you’re a very beginner, it really is not necessary to use gonna and wanna. I don’t even talk like that. And, it also had pages crammed with way too much material. It even overwhelmed me, and I speak English!
New Edition: Not Bad
Anyway, when I moved into the English department at my current university here in Korea, I was given Touchstone to teach from for my conversation classes. I let out a heavy sigh, remembering all my bad memories I’d had from years ago. But, upon digging into the lesson planning I changed my mind. Cambridge pulled it together for the second edition and the result is a pretty solid series of 4-skills ESL textbooks. Not the best I’ve ever used, but decent. And I didn’t hate it.
What I Like about Touchstone:
- The communicative activities in the back of the book are decent/passable. I used many of them, but they certainly could have been more fun. Throw in a board game here and there or something like that.
- The review sections at the end of every three chapters are great.
- I like the listening activities. They’re not all North-Americans, or native English speakers like many of the other ESL textbooks.
- The vocabulary sections are pretty good. There’s usually a lot of old, familiar words with a few new ones mixed in. This is how vocabulary should be learned.
- The workbook. I didn’t assign it for homework, but it was a fabulous way to make the midterm and final exams.
- The grammar and vocabulary practice sections are really good, moving from very controlled practice to free practice. They also generally start with pretty easy and progress to a few more difficult ones and are good at hitting the exceptions, if there are any for that specific grammar point.
What I Don’t Like about Touchstone:
- The grammar sections are confusing. I often had to take the ideas and make my own sort of chart or something for my students. What they have is just too complicated. For example, teaching all the future tenses together. Why would you just mix in random examples instead of making this rad chart like I did. See: Future Tense Chart. Cambridge: you can steal this from me for the next edition if you wish.
- Some topics were pretty weak. I felt like I had to skip at least a few of them in each book because my university students in Korea would have just not been interested.
My Rating for Touchstone: 3 Stars out of 5
Overall, I’d have to give the Touchstone series a 3/5. I most certainly wouldn’t choose to use it for any of my classes, if I were given the choice. I’d definitely go with 4 Corners, World Link, or even the less than stellar Smart Choice over Touchstone. All those books have solid grammar sections that aren’t confusing and are better at the communicative activities. If you’re looking for minimal lesson planning, 4 Corners in particular is excellent. Basically every single thing in that book is usable. Touchstone-maybe closer to 30 or 40%. For me to really love a textbook, it has to be up into the 70-80% range. 30% is just a whole lot more supplementary materials and lesson plans than I want to do.